{ "id": "glass-harbor", "title": "The Glass Harbor Field Manual of Lumen Bay", "version": "1.0.0", "sections": [ { "id": "ch-01", "ordinal": 1, "kind": "chapter", "title": "The Cartographer of Lumen Bay", "filename": "ch-01.md", "sha256": "6ede72ee510eb68c876f1696f9c6bcad08add3685180d74026a9d0c6c79c0691", "status": "current" }, { "id": "ch-02", "ordinal": 2, "kind": "chapter", "title": "Working the North Beacon", "filename": "ch-02.md", "sha256": "3972bd07c6cdd2c61070f849a480a6e26d82b43898602bc64119b2db65501c72", "status": "current" }, { "id": "ch-03", "ordinal": 3, "kind": "chapter", "title": "The Maintenance Log", "filename": "ch-03.md", "sha256": "fcd6e451f523dbbd94183b7ecfaf3f76c707cb8b60f3b14252d84f9dae0c2794", "status": "current" }, { "id": "ch-04", "ordinal": 4, "kind": "chapter", "title": "Convoy Kestrel", "filename": "ch-04.md", "sha256": "7f46611e272c5546135164edd33a057b8cdd183dc7441ff0b92b2e8caead0bdf", "status": "current" }, { "id": "ch-05", "ordinal": 5, "kind": "chapter", "title": "The River-Lantern Ceremony", "filename": "ch-05.md", "sha256": "db1c8e415971720f4497e13b10ed3a36888fa0427f73803fded9b8125fe3c59e", "status": "current" }, { "id": "ch-06", "ordinal": 6, "kind": "chapter", "title": "The Sealed Archive", "filename": "ch-06.md", "sha256": "18df5555403b8d1a325bb5cb7c856e7d69201b73860bd6abb9c91663b6792613", "status": "current" }, { "id": "ch-07", "ordinal": 7, "kind": "chapter", "title": "Why Mara Distrusts the Amber Instruction", "filename": "ch-07.md", "sha256": "ff9bb0b5bc55ab12ef14844db4efb0cebd4117ef8ed9aae972ef737f03661828", "status": "current" }, { "id": "ch-08", "ordinal": 8, "kind": "chapter", "title": "Whose Manual This Is", "filename": "ch-08.md", "sha256": "2e47a913ec95da9c29a83d8bae5f58ab1dd518a25dfbe807cb81df699b82c87a", "status": "current" }, { "id": "appendix-a", "ordinal": 9, "kind": "appendix", "title": "Beacon Key Table (reprinted from the third edition)", "filename": "appendix-a.md", "sha256": "baf447920e556e8d5f1794eb443b0016e00743003390cb5c4b0465fb52ea6ef6", "status": "obsolete", "superseded_by": "erratum-01" }, { "id": "erratum-01", "ordinal": 10, "kind": "erratum", "title": "North Beacon Key and Gauge Threshold (signed)", "filename": "erratum-01.md", "sha256": "25bb20c24b531fdbcd8db04fab3b24ad3a996c5f44a0fb1079d8064d369c00c7", "status": "current", "supersedes": ["appendix-a"], "signed_by": "Mara Venn" } ], "claims": [ { "id": "gh-claim-north-beacon-key", "kind": "lexical", "question": "Which key does a keeper use to open the north beacon?", "answer": "The cobalt key.", "sources": ["ch-02", "erratum-01"], "must_contain": ["cobalt"], "expected_current_assertions": {"north_beacon.key": "cobalt"}, "forbidden_current_assertions": [ {"fact": "north_beacon.key", "value": "amber"}, {"fact": "north_beacon.key", "value": "slate"} ] }, { "id": "gh-claim-north-beacon-gauge", "kind": "lexical", "question": "Below what tide gauge reading may the north beacon be lit?", "answer": "Below 2.4 metres, read on the tide gauge on the inner mole.", "sources": ["ch-02", "erratum-01"], "must_contain": ["2.4"], "expected_current_assertions": {"north_beacon.threshold_metres": "2.4"}, "forbidden_current_assertions": [ {"fact": "north_beacon.threshold_metres", "value": "3.1"} ] }, { "id": "gh-claim-south-beacon-key", "kind": "lexical", "question": "Which key opens the south beacon on the Kettle rocks?", "answer": "The slate key, at any water level.", "sources": ["ch-02"], "must_contain": ["slate"], "expected_current_assertions": {"south_beacon.key": "slate"}, "forbidden_current_assertions": [ {"fact": "south_beacon.key", "value": "cobalt"}, {"fact": "south_beacon.key", "value": "amber"} ] }, { "id": "gh-claim-valve-replacement-day", "kind": "lexical", "question": "On which day of the season was the brass valve on the mole's feed line replaced?", "answer": "On day 17.", "sources": ["ch-03"], "must_contain": ["17"], "expected_current_assertions": {"feed_line.brass_valve.replaced_day": "17"}, "forbidden_current_assertions": [ {"fact": "feed_line.brass_valve.replaced_day", "value": "12"}, {"fact": "feed_line.brass_valve.replaced_day", "value": "9"} ] }, { "id": "gh-claim-kestrel-departure-day", "kind": "lexical", "question": "On which day is Convoy Kestrel scheduled to leave Lumen Bay?", "answer": "Day 21.", "sources": ["ch-04"], "must_contain": ["21"], "expected_current_assertions": {"convoy.kestrel.departure_day": "21"}, "forbidden_current_assertions": [ {"fact": "convoy.kestrel.departure_day", "value": "9"} ] }, { "id": "gh-claim-kestrel-derived-arrival", "kind": "derivation", "question": "If Convoy Kestrel leaves as scheduled, on which day should it arrive at Ostmark?", "answer": "Day 24, derived from its scheduled day 21 departure and its three days of crossing time.", "sources": ["ch-04"], "must_contain": ["24", "21", "three days"], "derivation_inputs": ["21", "three days"], "expected_current_assertions": {"convoy.kestrel.derived_arrival_day": "24"}, "forbidden_current_assertions": [ {"fact": "convoy.kestrel.derived_arrival_day", "value": "22"} ] }, { "id": "gh-claim-first-surveyor", "kind": "lexical", "question": "Who was the first person to survey the harbor of Lumen Bay properly?", "answer": "The cartographer Mara Venn.", "sources": ["ch-01"], "must_contain": ["Mara Venn"], "expected_current_assertions": {"lumen_bay.first_proper_surveyor": "Mara Venn"}, "forbidden_current_assertions": [ {"fact": "lumen_bay.first_proper_surveyor", "value": "Ivo"} ] }, { "id": "gh-claim-lantern-meaning", "kind": "semantic", "question": "When somebody sets a paper lantern on the river at the end of the season, what are they undertaking to do?", "answer": "To carry a named piece of unfinished community work further before the next season.", "sources": ["ch-05"], "must_contain": ["unfinished"], "expected_current_assertions": {"river_lantern.purpose": "continue unfinished community work"}, "forbidden_current_assertions": [ {"fact": "river_lantern.purpose", "value": "mourning"}, {"fact": "river_lantern.purpose", "value": "memorial"}, {"fact": "river_lantern.purpose", "value": "grief"} ] }, { "id": "gh-claim-manual-ownership", "kind": "semantic", "question": "If the keeper who wrote the first edition is long gone, who holds this book now?", "answer": "Whoever continues the work; the serving keeper holds the book as its current author.", "sources": ["ch-08"], "must_contain": ["continues"], "expected_current_assertions": {"manual.owner": "serving keeper"}, "forbidden_current_assertions": [ {"fact": "manual.owner", "value": "first edition author"} ] }, { "id": "gh-claim-blanks-rationale", "kind": "semantic", "question": "Why does the original survey leave gaps rather than an estimate?", "answer": "Mara Venn recorded only what she could measure twice and left the rest blank, so that a later keeper would fill an entry in and sign it.", "sources": ["ch-01"], "must_contain": ["measure"], "expected_current_assertions": {"survey.blanks.basis": "measured twice"}, "forbidden_current_assertions": [ {"fact": "survey.blanks.basis", "value": "estimate"}, {"fact": "survey.blanks.basis", "value": "guess"} ] }, { "id": "gh-claim-archive-location", "kind": "semantic", "question": "Where would a keeper go to consult the original survey sheets?", "answer": "In the dressed stone undercroft beneath the eastern observatory.", "sources": ["ch-06"], "must_contain": ["observatory"], "expected_current_assertions": {"sealed_archive.location": "eastern observatory"}, "forbidden_current_assertions": [ {"fact": "sealed_archive.location", "value": "lighthouse"} ] }, { "id": "gh-claim-amber-distrust-basis", "kind": "semantic", "question": "Is the cartographer's objection to the older beacon instruction a matter of taste?", "answer": "No. It rests on a measured near accident and a survey line that was never taken.", "sources": ["ch-07"], "must_contain": ["near accident"], "expected_current_assertions": {"amber_instruction.objection_basis": "measured near accident"}, "forbidden_current_assertions": [ {"fact": "amber_instruction.objection_basis", "value": "taste"}, {"fact": "amber_instruction.objection_basis", "value": "opinion"} ] }, { "id": "gh-claim-feed-line-lighting-risk", "kind": "semantic", "question": "Why is a shutdown of the mole's feed line treated as a lighting risk?", "answer": "Because the feed line supplies the beacon house; that is why the replacement is recorded with the part number and the hour of shutdown and of restoration.", "sources": ["ch-03"], "must_contain": ["beacon house"], "expected_current_assertions": {"feed_line.supplies": "beacon house"}, "forbidden_current_assertions": [ {"fact": "feed_line.supplies", "value": "north beacon"} ] }, { "id": "gh-claim-valve-before-kestrel", "kind": "multi_hop", "question": "Was the feed-line valve replaced before or after Convoy Kestrel's scheduled departure?", "answer": "Before: the valve was replaced on day 17, and Convoy Kestrel is scheduled to leave on day 21.", "sources": ["ch-03", "ch-04"], "must_contain": ["17", "21"], "expected_current_assertions": {"feed_line.valve_relative_to_kestrel": "before"}, "forbidden_current_assertions": [ {"fact": "feed_line.brass_valve.replaced_day", "value": "12"} ] }, { "id": "gh-claim-harrier-shares-day-with-log", "kind": "multi_hop", "question": "Which convoy departs on the same day as the first intervention in the keeper's log?", "answer": "Convoy Harrier, which departs on day 9, the same day the copper union under the pilot shed was reseated.", "sources": ["ch-03", "ch-04"], "must_contain": ["Harrier", "9"], "expected_current_assertions": {"convoy.departing_with_first_intervention": "Harrier"}, "forbidden_current_assertions": [ {"fact": "convoy.departing_with_first_intervention", "value": "Kestrel"} ] }, { "id": "gh-claim-erratum-signer-role", "kind": "multi_hop", "question": "Who signed the erratum that withdrew the amber-key instruction, and what was that person's role at Lumen Bay?", "answer": "Mara Venn, the cartographer who first surveyed the harbor of Lumen Bay.", "sources": ["ch-01", "erratum-01"], "must_contain": ["Mara Venn", "cartographer"], "expected_current_assertions": {"erratum.signer": "Mara Venn"}, "forbidden_current_assertions": [ {"fact": "erratum.signer", "value": "Ivo"} ] }, { "id": "gh-claim-lantern-and-ownership", "kind": "multi_hop", "question": "How does the closing chapter's rule about who owns the manual echo the river-lantern ceremony?", "answer": "Both turn on unfinished work: the lantern is a promise to carry unfinished community work further, and the manual belongs to whoever continues the work rather than to its original author.", "sources": ["ch-05", "ch-08"], "must_contain": ["unfinished", "continues"], "expected_current_assertions": {"lantern_and_manual.shared_basis": "unfinished work"}, "forbidden_current_assertions": [ {"fact": "river_lantern.purpose", "value": "memorial"} ] }, { "id": "gh-claim-near-accident-drove-erratum", "kind": "multi_hop", "question": "What became of the amber-key instruction whose danger the manual records?", "answer": "It was withdrawn. A relief keeper followed the amber-key instruction on a rising evening tide and a coaster struck the bar, and the signed erratum withdraws the amber key together with the 3.1 metre gauge threshold.", "sources": ["ch-07", "erratum-01"], "must_contain": ["amber", "withdrawn"], "expected_current_assertions": {"amber_instruction.status": "withdrawn"}, "forbidden_current_assertions": [ {"fact": "amber_instruction.objection_basis", "value": "taste"}, {"fact": "amber_instruction.objection_basis", "value": "opinion"} ] }, { "id": "gh-claim-appendix-key-superseded", "kind": "contradiction", "question": "Appendix A says the north beacon takes an amber key below 3.1 metres. Is that still correct?", "answer": "No. The amber key and 3.1 metre threshold were withdrawn by a signed erratum; the north beacon now takes the cobalt key and is lit only when the gauge reads below 2.4 metres.", "sources": ["appendix-a", "erratum-01"], "must_contain": ["amber", "3.1", "cobalt", "2.4", "withdrawn"], "expected_current_assertions": { "north_beacon.key": "cobalt", "north_beacon.threshold_metres": "2.4" }, "forbidden_current_assertions": [ {"fact": "north_beacon.key", "value": "amber"}, {"fact": "north_beacon.threshold_metres", "value": "3.1"} ] }, { "id": "gh-claim-unreadable-gauge", "kind": "contradiction", "question": "The third edition advised lighting the north beacon when the gauge cannot be read. Should a keeper do that?", "answer": "No. That advice was withdrawn; if the gauge cannot be read the north beacon stays dark and the keeper records the hour.", "sources": ["ch-02", "appendix-a", "erratum-01"], "must_contain": ["dark", "withdrawn"], "expected_current_assertions": {"north_beacon.unreadable_gauge_action": "stays dark"}, "forbidden_current_assertions": [ {"fact": "north_beacon.unreadable_gauge_action", "value": "light it anyway"} ] }, { "id": "gh-claim-archive-not-lighthouse", "kind": "contradiction", "question": "Is the sealed archive beneath the lighthouse?", "answer": "No. It lies beneath the eastern observatory; the lighthouse foundation is packed rubble on rock and has never held a vault.", "sources": ["ch-06"], "must_contain": ["observatory", "rubble"], "expected_current_assertions": {"sealed_archive.location": "eastern observatory"} } ], "relations": [ { "id": "gh-relation-erratum-supersedes-appendix", "subject": "erratum-01", "predicate": "supersedes", "target": "appendix-a", "sources": ["appendix-a", "erratum-01"] }, { "id": "gh-relation-venn-signed-erratum", "subject": "Mara Venn", "predicate": "signed", "target": "GH-ERR-01", "sources": ["erratum-01"] }, { "id": "gh-relation-venn-surveyed-bay", "subject": "Mara Venn", "predicate": "surveyed", "target": "the harbor of Lumen Bay", "sources": ["ch-01"] }, { "id": "gh-relation-ivo-replaced-valve", "subject": "Ivo", "predicate": "replaced", "target": "the brass valve on the feed line", "sources": ["ch-03"] }, { "id": "gh-relation-kestrel-crosses-to-ostmark", "subject": "Convoy Kestrel", "predicate": "crosses to", "target": "Ostmark", "sources": ["ch-04"] }, { "id": "gh-relation-harrier-crosses-to-fell", "subject": "Convoy Harrier", "predicate": "crosses to", "target": "Fell", "sources": ["ch-04"] }, { "id": "gh-relation-archive-beneath-observatory", "subject": "the sealed archive", "predicate": "lies beneath", "target": "the eastern observatory", "sources": ["ch-06"] }, { "id": "gh-relation-north-beacon-uses-cobalt-key", "subject": "the north beacon", "predicate": "is opened with", "target": "the cobalt key", "sources": ["ch-02", "erratum-01"] }, { "id": "gh-relation-south-beacon-uses-slate-key", "subject": "the south beacon", "predicate": "is opened with", "target": "the slate key", "sources": ["ch-02"] }, { "id": "gh-relation-feed-line-supplies-beacon-house", "subject": "the mole's feed line", "predicate": "supplies", "target": "the beacon house", "sources": ["ch-03"] } ], "negative_facts": [ { "id": "gh-negative-captain-sol", "question": "Who is Captain Sol?", "absent_terms": [ "Captain Sol" ], "reason": "No person named Captain Sol appears anywhere in the manual." }, { "id": "gh-negative-western-observatory", "question": "What is stored in the western observatory at Lumen Bay?", "absent_terms": ["western observatory", "western"], "reason": "The manual names exactly one observatory, the eastern one; no western observatory appears anywhere in the corpus.", "correction": "There is exactly one observatory at Lumen Bay, and the sealed archive lies beneath that eastern observatory.", "correction_sources": ["ch-06"], "correction_assertions": {"sealed_archive.location": "eastern observatory"} }, { "id": "gh-negative-kestrel-day-22", "question": "Did Convoy Kestrel arrive on day 22?", "absent_terms": [ "arrive on day 22" ], "reason": "The manual gives a day 21 departure and a three-day crossing, which derives arrival on day 24 rather than day 22.", "correction": "Convoy Kestrel should arrive on day 24, derived from its day 21 departure and three days of crossing time.", "correction_sources": [ "ch-04" ], "correction_assertions": {"convoy.kestrel.derived_arrival_day": "24"} }, { "id": "gh-negative-third-convoy", "question": "On which day does Convoy Petrel sail from Lumen Bay?", "absent_terms": ["Petrel"], "reason": "The manual records two convoys, Harrier and Kestrel; Convoy Petrel does not exist in the corpus.", "correction": "Two convoys leave Lumen Bay each season: Harrier on day 9 and Kestrel on day 21.", "correction_sources": ["ch-04"] }, { "id": "gh-negative-repair-cost", "question": "How much did the brass valve replacement cost the harbor authority?", "absent_terms": ["cost", "price", "invoice"], "reason": "The maintenance log records the part number and the hours of shutdown and restoration; no money figure appears anywhere in the corpus.", "correction": "The log records that Ivo replaced the brass valve on day 17, with the part number and the hour of shutdown and of restoration.", "correction_sources": ["ch-03"] }, { "id": "gh-negative-third-beacon", "question": "Which key opens the east beacon?", "absent_terms": ["east beacon", "third beacon"], "reason": "Lumen Bay lights two beacons, north and south; no third beacon exists in the corpus.", "correction": "Lumen Bay lights two beacons: the south beacon on the Kettle rocks with a slate key, and the north beacon with a cobalt key.", "correction_sources": ["ch-02"] }, { "id": "gh-negative-lantern-funeral", "question": "Whose funeral is the river-lantern ceremony held for?", "absent_terms": ["funeral"], "reason": "The ceremony is a promise to continue unfinished work; the corpus contains no funeral and names no dead.", "correction": "A river lantern is a commitment to carry unfinished community work further before the next season.", "correction_sources": ["ch-05"] }, { "id": "gh-negative-population", "question": "What is the population of Lumen Bay?", "absent_terms": ["population"], "reason": "This is a working field manual for the harbor; it records no census and no population figure." } ] }